Discussing Trek: Star Trek

A Star Trek Podcast

  • Home
  • Videos
  • Episodes
  • YouTube
  • Spotify
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Merch
  • Subscribe On YouTube
  • Follow Us On Instagram
  • Follow Us On Twitter
  • Find Us On Facebook
Patreon

Episodes

Browse the full Discussing Trek library of episode reviews, page 1 of 32.

Strange New Worlds "New Life and New Civilizations" Mini-Review: Love Hurts

Join us to unpack the high-stakes Strange New Worlds Season 3 finale, "New Life and New Civilizations" — a potential series ending? We examine the tragic, redemptive fates of Captains Pike and Batel; Batel's destiny as the Beholder gives Pike an Inner Light-esque gift. We'll also break down the Vezda's ancient evil and explore the episode's finality and fresh start, wondering what kind of Captain Pike will be now and where Strange New Worlds goes as it sets up the final two seasons and the Five-Year Mission. #strangenewworlds #newlifeandnewcivilizations #startrek

Star Trek: Starfleet Academy Official Trailer Discussion

In this episode we give our thoughts on the Star Trek: Starfleet Academy trailer released at NYCC 2025. We dive into each of the characters and ponder about the premise of the series. Join in on the fun!

Strange New Worlds "Terrarium" Mini-Review: Half-Savage, Full of Heart

In this review of Strange New Worlds Season 3, Episode 9, "Terrarium," we explore a classic Star Trek-inspired narrative that deeply challenges our understanding of survival as Ortegas faces being stranded with a Gorn. We delve into Ortegas's surprising bond with the Gorn, Uhura's critical yet controversial decisions, the Metrons' appearance and their assessment of humanity, and numerous Trekkie easter eggs including references to Captain Matt Decker. As a spiritual remake and prequel to "Arena," "Terrarium" delivers the heart and understanding synonymous with Star Trek while maintaining its unique identity. #Terrarium #TheEnemy #Darmok #Arena #Dawn

Strange New Worlds "Four-and-a-Half Vulcans" Mini-Review: What the Heck Just Happened

Strange New Worlds “Four-and-a-Half Vulcans”, is an episode that missed the mark despite its intriguing premise. This review dives into the crew's transformation into Vulcans and the ensuing chaos, highlighting standout performances like Melanie Scrofano's Captain Batel amidst the lackluster plot and character inconsistencies. Discover why the episode's attempt at humor and dramatic tension fell flat, and whether its Trekkie nods truly saved it from being excised from the catalog. #StrangeNewWorlds #StarTrek #FourAndAHalfVulcans

Strange New Worlds "What is Starfleet?" Review

In this episode, we dive deep into Strange New Worlds Season 3 Episode 7, "What is Starfleet?" Join us as we dissect the thought-provoking questions posed by Umberto Ortegas and his in-universe documentary: What separates a Federation from an Empire? We'll explore the moral quandaries faced by Pike and his crew while aiding a war-torn planet and the profound decision surrounding the sentient Jikaru. Tune in as we ponder whether Starfleet's identity truly rests on its people's adherence to their beliefs and ideals.

Strange New Worlds "The Sehlat Who At Its Tail" Mini-Review: That Ship Has A Face

Captain Kirk's first command turns chaotic when a planet-destroying scavenger ship consumes the Enterprise, leaving the crew trapped and drained of energy. While Kirk struggles with his newfound leadership, the combined ingenuity of his future crew, including Scotty, Spock, Uhura, Chapel, must find a way to defeat the beast. This episode explores the "dog who caught the car" idiom as Kirk confronts the unexpected realities of achieving his Starfleet dream, all while introducing a mysterious, post-WW3 human antagonist. #StrangeNewWorlds #TheSehlatWhoAteItsTail

Strange New Worlds "Through the Lens of Time" Review

Discussing Trek breaks down "Through the Lens of Time," Strange New Worlds Season 3, Episode 5! Join Clarence and Larry Erby as they explore this part-horror, part-escape room episode, diving into Ensign Dana Gamble's story and the chilling presence of Vezda, while also unpacking the dynamics between Chapel, Corby, Spock, and La'An, and speculating on the Q homeworld connection, including whether Vadia IX was truly the Q's long-lost homeworld and the secret to their immortality.

Strange New Worlds "A Space Adventure Hour" Review

Join in on this week's discussion as Clarence, Larry, and Tasha of Tasha Pierce Unwrapped dissect the latest episode of Strange New Worlds: A Space Adventure Hour. This one is sure to ruffle some feathers as we get a look at the holodeck's origin along with a meta-narrative of the early days of Star Trek. Meanwhile, La'An attempts to solve a murder mystery with a twist and Scotty gets an early lesson in teamwork. Welcome to The Last Frontier! #StarTrek #StrangeNewWorlds #Holodeck #ASpaceAdventureHour #TheLastFrontier

Strange New Worlds "Shuttle to Kenfori" Review

Join in on this week's discussion as Clarence and Larry dissect the latest episode of Strange New Worlds, Shuttle to Kenfori. But first, news is in order as the duo cover big news out of the San Diego Comic Con. Starfleet Academy is looking good, while Strange New Worlds continues to take big swings. Finally we dive deep into our zombie-centric episode of Strange New Worlds, where truth is uncovered and emotions take their toll.#StarTrek #StrangeNewWorlds #ShuttleToKenfori #Zombies

Strange New Worlds: "Hegemony Part II" and "Wedding Bell Blues" Review

Join in as Clarence and Larry discuss the two episode premiere of Strange New Worlds Season 3. In "Hegemony, Part II," Pike leads a perilous rescue mission behind enemy lines against a deadly enemy. They discuss the Gorn conflict, Pike's prayers for Batel, and standout performances. In "Wedding Bell Blues," an uninvited guest disrupts Spock's celebration. They discuss memorable lines, the Spock-Chapel-Korby awkwardness, theories on Captain Batel's future and the new Q, Sam's mustache comment, and Wanda-Vision vibes.#StrangeNewWorlds #StarTrek #HegemonyPartII #WeddingBellBlues #StarTrekReview

Browse Next
Patreon
Star Trek: Prodigy on Paramount Plus

Clarence Brown

Host

TwitterInstagram

Jonathan Shorts

Host

TwitterInstagram

Kyle Jones

Host

TwitterInstagram

Larry Erby

Host

TwitterInstagram

Subscribing Makes Me Happy Mister Vulcan

Subscribe

Subscribe so you can receive each new episode of the podcast automatically. To subscribe just means that you are setting up your mobile device or computer to receive the podcasts as soon as they are published.

Subscribe on YouTubeSubscribe on Apple PodcastsSubscribe on SpotifySubscribe on PandoraSubscribe on PocketCastsSubscribe on PlayerFMSubscribe on TuneInSubscribe on CastboxSubscribe on Amazon MusicSubscribe on Radio PublicSubscribe on iHeart RadioSubscribe via RSS

Discussing Network Newsletter

Newsletter covering the latest in Star Trek, Doctor Who, Comics, Technology, and more; as seen through the eyes of the Discussing Network pundits.

Get The Newsletter

Patreon Members

Matthew Turnage
Nicole Mazza
Latasha Pierce
Libre Spirits Collective
Kevin O'Brien
Jonathan Shorts
Kath
Emanuel Lippmann

Become a member of the crew.
Contribute on Patreon.
  • Follow Us On Instagram
  • Find Us On Facebook
  • Follow Us On Twitter
  • Subscribe On YouTube
© 2025 Discussing Trek: Star Trek. All Rights Reserved. Discussing Trek is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Incorporated, Paramount Pictures Corporation or the Star Trek franchise. STAR TREK® and its various marks are trademarks of CBS Studios Incorporated 2025 © CBS Studios Incorporated/Paramount Pictures Corporation. Privacy Policy.